If you call a bonus baby greedy, you should also call him smart

Sure seems like Eric Hosmer is taking some heat from fans, and on some level, that's predictable.

He gave Royals fans a scare by insisting he'd have been happy going to Arizona State if the Royals' offer wasn't sufficient, and then another scare by taking negotiations down to the very last minute.

The quick and natural reaction from fans is disgust that a high school kid would hold out so long and so hard for millions of dollars to have the chance to fulfill a dream.

The $6 million check Hosmer will cash is among the highest bonuses ever given to a baseball draft pick. It's enough money to set his family up for generations, depending on how he handles it, and he's only 18 with zero professional at bats.

That makes for an easy target, the greedy punk kid trying to drain a team for every cent he can before he proves he's worth it.

But you know what? He did the right thing.

Doing anything else would've been stupid and irresponsible.

As can't-miss as we hear Hosmer is, take a look at other guys who went third overall in the draft. It's not a sure thing.

Oh, there's Evan Longoria and Troy Glaus and some other solid big leaguers.

But there's also Luis Montanez, Dewon Brazelton, and B.J. Wallace. Kyle Sleeth went in that spot five years ago, and he's already retired without ever making it to the big leagues.

Brazelton was in camp with the Royals last year, and drove a Hummer every day to the ballpark. You think he's not glad he got every dollar he could?

Baseball scouts and officials often call these huge bonuses "failure money," the idea being this is how much cash you have if you fail as a pro ballplayer.

That's fine, and their frustration is understandable considering the pain (both in effort and wallet) it's become to sign these premier picks. But it's those same executives who created this mess, and if they're honest, they'll admit that.

Nobody is forcing them to pay millions to high school kids. They're doing it because they think it's worth it, and if it's worth it to them, why shouldn't the kids on the other end make sure they get all the money they can?

Every indication is that Eric Hosmer will turn into a premier hitter in the big leagues, enormous power with a high average, and Gold Glove potential at first base, too.

Maybe he breezes through the minor leagues, breaks Steve Balboni's home run record, makes a couple All-Star teams and then signs a nine-figure free agent contract. That's the dream.

But there's also a very real possibility that the check he's about to cash will be the biggest payday he ever sees.

Maybe he gets hurt, or maybe he doesn't adjust to wood bats, or pro pitching, or maybe he gets stuck for any of the reasons that thousands of good prospects before him have failed in the minor leagues.

If anything like that happens, don't you think he'll be grateful he cashed in when he could?

Submitted by Sam Mellinger on August 19, 2008 - 7:31am.
| login or register to post comments
Submitted by crawford on August 19, 2008 - 12:00pm.

I'm here to eat my plate of crow. Glass came through in spades Friday night and signed Hosmer. I have castigated ownership for the better part of 4 years for being cheap on their draft picks and sinking the franchise. But they came through Friday.

No only did they spend more than the franchise ever has - they spent more than any franchise ever has on a draft - period. And what a haul, 3 of the top 10 HS pitchers, and the best bat in HS this year. If the Royals keep drafting this high, and this aggressivly, in 1 or 2 more years they will have the best farm system in the league, hands down.

I'm shocked, bewildered. but i'm extreamly happy with the direction the franchise went. Could not have asked for anything more.

But more to the point: Gordan Beckham - 2.6, Yonder Alonso, 2.0, Justin Smoak 3.5. Hosmer cost 3 to 4 million more - that's one year of Ross Gload or Yabuta. Hosmer, depending on the service time, you have him for at least 4 years. it's a no brainer.

"fixing the draft" - if i'm Dayton Moore I fight tooth and nail to keep the system as is for a few more years. I think that's when the next CBA is, actually. But anyway, If you pick in the top 5, get a supplemental rounder and are willing to spend for 2 1st round talents and a couple more 2nd-ish rounders...he could not ask for a better way to get the franchise back on track than drafts like 2008

Submitted by lakewoodroyal on August 19, 2008 - 12:54pm.

like your post and agree. If you are at the top of the heap, you have to expect to pay for the top talent. However, if you draft, say, 15th, this is where slotting would definitely help. Protect clubs from agents like Boras who advise their clients to holdout. I don't believe a cap should be in place, but slotting would be good for all involved (except the agent).

Submitted by jayhawkowensjunior on August 19, 2008 - 9:00am.

Was he supposed to, I don't know, give it back? Say "Thanks, but I'd like to show you I've earned this first?" Apologize for joining one of the few industries in which the employees actually receive a portion of the revenue vaguely in line with their production? Get down on his hands and knees and thank the Almighty for the unique privilege of joining the Kansas City Royals organization? Give half of his check to Mr. Ron Smith, 42, Leawood, because Mr. Smith's been such a good fan through the last twenty years of Royals misery and he's therefore totally earned it?

Submitted by lakewoodroyal on August 19, 2008 - 8:45am.

I don't fault the kid at all. Its a tough decision when you are 18 and have the option of hanging out at Arizona State as a BMOC during prime tail-chasing years. That alone might be worth a few million, let alone his baseball talent. To be as cliche as possible, salaries are what they are. Unless the big market owners are willing to come down from their perch and agree to cap limits and slotting, there is not much use in complaining about it. George's boys just took over the trust fund so its not going to happen for awhile.

Lets be careful about Hosmer. The ink isn't even dry yet and we have another can't miss, Balboni trumping, sure-fire All-Star playing DH/1B right now who has arguably regressed from last year.

Submitted by MB on August 19, 2008 - 10:12pm.

Balboni was the man. I remember watching him catch a grounder with a man on first, step on the bag and then frantically sail the ball over the 2nd baseman's head into left field. He hung his head in shame for a bit as the boos came down. But on his next at bat, he deposited one over the left-center wall like he meant it.

That's baseball, baby.

Just got back from (old) Yankees Stadium where people still believe promising players are worth Hosmer kind of money.

As I walked in, I was told to pay attention, that Yankees fans are different than everywhere else. I was also told I might want to take off my KC cap. Soon, after a few innings, I didn't believe a word of it.

On Saturday, after 13 innings of sunny frustration, I walked out of that miserably confined stadium and headed for the bars in the East Village. A worn out KC cap still firmly on my head, I ran into a lot of people who asked if I'd been golfing or boating that day. When I told them no, I went to the game, I wasn't surprised when they asked who won. I came away thinking that if KC had a population of a bazillion, we'd have 40 grand faithful at the K every day, too.

And I just read the Star's Chief's blog ... America's game has obviously changed ... and it's a pitiful boor.

This is Major League Baseball we're talking about. Beer is overpriced and so are the seats. Go for it, Mr. Glass. Spend a few bucks and don't even question it. Let's get some good guys and go kick some Yankee, Red Sox, White Sox, and Twinkies asses next year.

We deserve it and so do they.

Submitted by lakewoodroyal on August 20, 2008 - 8:23am.

Can we get MB on a flight to AR?

Submitted by Sam Mellinger on August 20, 2008 - 7:22am.

....the post of the year?

Submitted by jtuck123 on August 20, 2008 - 8:08am.

...
JT

User login

Recent comments

Interviews

Gil Meche: The older brother of the Royals' rotation talks bowling, collecting baseball cards, and sliders

Gil Meche: The older brother of the Royals' rotation talks bowling, collecting baseball cards, and sliders

Very good first-day turnout on Twitter. Thank you. If you're on and haven't found me, I'm at "mellinger." Let's join up, we'll have fun.

You may have noticed we didn't have an MGD update after the weekend, and that's because of a bonus weekend post on SI coverboy/comedian Zack Greinke, and that Davies' start on Thursday means we won't miss a week with an MGD update.

READ MORE...

Submitted by Sam Mellinger on April 28, 2009 - 7:52am.
| read more | 6 comments

Zack Greinke: Ball Star's most requested interview subject talks trucks, fighting, and trash

Zack Greinke, for a lot of reasons, might be the most interesting player on the Royals roster, and this is a team that includes an outfielder who owns lions and ostriches and likes to be slapped in the face, a pitcher who was knighted by his native Aruba, another who works construction in the offseason, and a reliever who body slams opposing players and prides himself on his baking.

Greinke is the most-requested interview for this blog, and if you act now, you can read a bonus interview where Kyle Davies defends himself against what he alleges is Greinke's slander. All in good fun.

READ MORE...

Submitted by Sam Mellinger on March 26, 2009 - 8:41am.
| read more | 11 comments

Army Maj. Michael Lalor: Rooting on the Royals from Iraq

Confession time. That "contest" we ran here
was officially won by Tom Barkwell from Madagascar, and I loved both his words and the fact that he sent them from an island nation in the Indian Ocean, but I gotta tell you, it wasn't my favorite letter.

Nope, my favorite came from Army Maj. Michael Lalor, whose words came from Iraq.

I didn't mention this in the original contest because I wanted to give Michael his own post. He was kind enough to answer some questions over e-mail, which we're turning into the latest interview. His letter is below our e-mail exchange.

READ MORE...

Submitted by Sam Mellinger on September 19, 2008 - 7:07am.
| read more | 12 comments

Royals Gear